The House of No Return
The Story
A young couple moves into their dream home after a hopeful new beginning, but within moments of stepping inside, a hidden explosion turns their future into a deadly mystery that investigators struggle to unravel.Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/dark-american-crime--7005371/support.
Thanks for listening to Dark American Crime. The next episode is coming soon.
This episode includes AI-generated content.
Speaker 1: On the night of May twenty first, nineteen ninety three,
Speaker 1: in rural Iowa, a small church basement glowed with warmth
Speaker 1: and laughter. Friends and family of Kem wing Anger had
Speaker 1: gathered at the Golden Congregational Church for what was meant
Speaker 1: to be a celebration, a combined wedding shower and farewell
Speaker 1: party for Kem and her fiancee, Kurt Simon. Kem stood
Speaker 1: at the center of it all, clapping her hands with
Speaker 1: joy as a handmade money tree was presented to her
Speaker 1: and Kurt. It wasn't extravagant by any means, just a
Speaker 1: simple coffee and painted yellow with envelopes of cash hanging
Speaker 1: from its branches, but to Kem it meant everything. It
Speaker 1: was proof that people cared that their new beginning was supported,
Speaker 1: even if everyone there lived modestly. Kurt stood beside her,
Speaker 1: smiling quietly as always. At thirty two, he was studying
Speaker 1: to become a Presbyterian minister, trying to finish seminary school
Speaker 1: while juggling the uncertainty of his future. Kem twenty nine,
Speaker 1: had her own ruggles, two children from previous relationships, financial instability,
Speaker 1: and a recent job loss after workplace harassment forced her
Speaker 1: to leave her office position. Life had not been easy
Speaker 1: for either of them, but they believed they had found
Speaker 1: something steady in each other. After only eight months together,
Speaker 1: sparked by a blind date that neither of them expected
Speaker 1: much from, they had decided to build a life together.
Speaker 1: Kem would move from Bloomington, Illinois, to Iowa to be
Speaker 1: with Kurt, and then they would return to Bloomington as
Speaker 1: a family. They talked about marriage, about Kurt adopting Kem's
Speaker 1: young son, about stability, about finally breathing again. Felt like
Speaker 1: a turning point. Even the church's small gift felt symbolic,
Speaker 1: like the start of a new chapter. But not everything
Speaker 1: in Kem's life was peaceful. Her relationships with the fathers
Speaker 1: of her children were strained. Dale Fosdick, the father of
Speaker 1: her son, frequently argued with her over access and support,
Speaker 1: often ignoring boundaries. Todd w Anger, the father of her daughter,
Speaker 1: was locked in bitter custody disputes with her. And then
Speaker 1: there was Km's mother, Cricket, estranged, volatile and openly hostile
Speaker 1: toward Kurt. Still, on that night, none of it seemed
Speaker 1: to matter. Not yet. When the party ended, Kem and
Speaker 1: Kurt left the church holding hands, stepping into the quiet
Speaker 1: Iowa night, unaware of how quickly everything in their lives
Speaker 1: was about to change. The next day, May twenty second
Speaker 1: began like any other day of moving chaos. Boxes were packed, loaded, stacked,
Speaker 1: and carried. The couple spent hours preparing for the two
Speaker 1: hundred thirty mile drive to Bloomington, Illinois, where Kem's house
Speaker 1: waited for them. By the time evening arrived, exhaustion had
Speaker 1: settled into their bones. At around ten thirty pm, they
Speaker 1: finally pulled into the driveway of Km's two story home.
Speaker 1: Street lights flickered softly as Kurt stepped out, first, opening
Speaker 1: the trunk and lifting boxes toward the house. Among them
Speaker 1: was the small money tree from the church. Kem stayed
Speaker 1: seated in the passenger seat for a moment, too tired
Speaker 1: to move. She watched Kurt carry items up the front steps,
Speaker 1: unlock the door, and disappear inside. A minute later, he
Speaker 1: returned empty handed. Kem sided gathered a box and followed him.
Speaker 1: She walked toward the house, slowly, stepping into the foyer
Speaker 1: of what was now supposed to be her shared home.
Speaker 1: But something was wrong. The moment she entered, she noticed
Speaker 1: something on the floor, something unfamiliar, something that hadn't been
Speaker 1: there before. Before she could process it further, everything changed outside.
Speaker 1: Kurt was near the car when it happened. A violent,
Speaker 1: crushing force slammed into him from behind. Felt like the
Speaker 1: world itself had exploded. A deafening boom followed, so loud
Speaker 1: it seemed to swallow the night. He stumbled forward, nearly falling,
Speaker 1: his ears ringing. When he turned around, smoke was already
Speaker 1: pouring from the front of the house. Cam He shouted,
Speaker 1: but his voice felt distant, swallowed by the ringing in
Speaker 1: his ears, He ran inside. The house had transformed into chaos.
Speaker 1: The foyer was filled with thick smoke, shattered glass, and
Speaker 1: fragments of debris scattered across every surface. The air was
Speaker 1: hot and choking. Kurt called Kem's name again and again,
Speaker 1: stumbling forward blindly. Then he saw it, pair of legs
Speaker 1: on the floor. Detective Larry Shepherd arrived within minutes, responding
Speaker 1: to reports of a possible explosion, but the moment he
Speaker 1: stepped out of his car, he knew this was not
Speaker 1: a simple blast. The house was vomiting smoke from its entrance.
Speaker 1: Neighbors were screaming, pointing, running in panic. The street was
Speaker 1: littered with splintered wood, glass and twisted fragments of metal,
Speaker 1: and in the drivewat a man Kurt, shouting Kem's name
Speaker 1: over and over, shaking. Devastated. Shepherd didn't wait. He and
Speaker 1: his partner rushed inside. The foyer was a nightmare. Smoke
Speaker 1: hung in the air like a curtain. There was no
Speaker 1: active fire, only destruction. A hole had been blown through
Speaker 1: the floor, another in the wall, and at the center
Speaker 1: of it all was Kem wing anger. There was nothing
Speaker 1: that could be done for her. The damage was unmistakable.
Speaker 1: Whatever had detonated here was not a simple device. It
Speaker 1: was deliberate, powerful and precise. Shepherd stepped back, immediately, ordering
Speaker 1: the area secured and calling for the bomb squad and
Speaker 1: fire department. This was not a typical crime scene. This
Speaker 1: was something far more dangerous. In the hours that followed,
Speaker 1: suspicion fell quickly and heavily on Kurt Simon. He had
Speaker 1: been the first to enter the house. He had carried
Speaker 1: boxes inside. Neighbors had seen him moving back and forth
Speaker 1: between the car and the house, and most damning of all,
Speaker 1: bomb making materials were discovered in the basement wires, gunpowder,
Speaker 1: and fuses. To investigators, it looked like a homemade explosive
Speaker 1: had been constructed inside the home. Kurt became the immediate focus,
Speaker 1: but as detectives dug deeper, inconsistencies began to appear. Kurt
Speaker 1: insisted he had been outside when the explosion happened. Neighbors
Speaker 1: suggested timing that didn't fully align with his version of events,
Speaker 1: yet nothing concrete tied him to the device itself. His
Speaker 1: car showed nothing suspicious, his movements in Iowa prior to
Speaker 1: the incident were confirmed, and Kem's friends consistently described their
Speaker 1: relationship as loving and stable. The investigation expanded, Dale Fosdick
Speaker 1: and Todd wing Anger were both examined closely. Both had
Speaker 1: strained relationships with chemistry, Both had motives rooted in custody,
Speaker 1: disputes and resentment. Both had alibis that were difficult but
Speaker 1: not impossible to challenge. Then came another unsettling detail. A
Speaker 1: spare key to Kem's house had gone missing, and earlier,
Speaker 1: Kem had been forced to break into her own home
Speaker 1: through a damaged screen door. Access had been possible for
Speaker 1: almost anyone. The suspect Pool widened again. A coworker Kem
Speaker 1: had previously accused of harassment, Phil Hartman, also entered the investigation.
Speaker 1: He had allegedly threatened her after a workplace dispute, but
Speaker 1: records showed he was hundreds of miles away at the time. Still,
Speaker 1: nothing was ruled out. By Sunday night, exhaustion weighed heavily
Speaker 1: on Detective Shepherd. He had been awake for more than
Speaker 1: a day, running through interviews, contradictions, and dead ends. When
Speaker 1: he visited Kem's estranged family members, the situation only grew
Speaker 1: more complicated. Kem's sister was grieving, but Kem's mother, Cricket,
Speaker 1: displayed a disturbing focus not on the laws itself, but
Speaker 1: on inheritance and life insurance. She expressed anger that she
Speaker 1: would not benefit financially from her daughter's death. Her hostility
Speaker 1: toward Kurt was intense and unfiltered, painting him as the
Speaker 1: root of all family problems. At the same time, she
Speaker 1: defended Kem's former partner Dale, suggesting he had been the
Speaker 1: better man, another layer of confusion, another possible suspect. By Monday,
Speaker 1: the scene had been cleared enough for full forensic examination.
Speaker 1: What investigators determined changed everything. The device had not been
Speaker 1: remotely triggered, it had not been timed, it had been
Speaker 1: motion activated. Kem had likely picked up the package, perhaps
Speaker 1: out of curiosity, perhaps thinking it had been left for her,
Speaker 1: and that single movement had triggered the explosion. This meant
Speaker 1: the bomb could have been placed hours or even days earlier.
Speaker 1: It also meant the attacker did not need to be
Speaker 1: present when it detonated. They only needed access and confidence
Speaker 1: and familiarity with the home. As detectives stood in the
Speaker 1: ruined foyer, one conclusion began to form. Whoever had done
Speaker 1: this new Keem well enough to enter her home without
Speaker 1: raising suspicion, Someone who belonged there, someone the neighborhood recognized.
Speaker 1: A breakthrough came when investigators recanvassed the area with this
Speaker 1: new understanding. They asked neighbors not just about the night
Speaker 1: of the explosion, but about the days before it. And
Speaker 1: then a child came forward. She described seeing a familiar
Speaker 1: man near Kem's house, someone who waved at her casually
Speaker 1: as if he belonged there. That man was Dale Fosdick.
Speaker 1: Dale had access, Dale was known in the neighborhood. Dale
Speaker 1: had motive, rooted in jealousy, custody, disputes and resentment over
Speaker 1: Kim's new relationship with Kurt, and talk of Kurt adopting
Speaker 1: his son. Investigators dug deeper. Forensic evidence, witness accounts, and
Speaker 1: behavioral patterns began to slowly the focus narrowed, and eventually
Speaker 1: it became clear Dale Fosdick had used his familiarity with
Speaker 1: Kem's home and his access within the community to carry
Speaker 1: out the attack. The investigation concluded he had built and
Speaker 1: placed a motion activated explosive device inside the house, knowing
Speaker 1: he would not need to be present when it detonated.
Speaker 1: Months later, he was arrested and convicted of first degree murder.
Speaker 1: He was sentenced to sixty one years in prison. He
Speaker 1: served only fourteen before dying in custody in twenty ten.
Speaker 1: What began as a hopeful new chapter for Kem wing
Speaker 1: Anger and Kurt Simon ended in an instant of devastation.
Speaker 1: An ordinary moven Knight turned into one of the most
Speaker 1: violent crimes in Bloomington's history, and in the aftermath, investigators
Speaker 1: were left with a haunting reminder. Sometimes the most dangerous
Speaker 1: person is not a stranger, It is the one who
Speaker 1: never truly left your life,
Podbean